SPD or SPD-SL: which clipless pedal system suits you?
Clipless pedals come in two main kinds that are not interchangeable. The choice also decides which shoes you need. Here is how to choose well.
The difference in one table
| SPD (MTB/gravel) | SPD-SL and other road systems | |
|---|---|---|
| Cleat | Small metal, 2 bolts | Large plastic, 3 bolts |
| Walking | Good, cleat is recessed | Awkward, cleat protrudes |
| Contact area | Smaller | Large, stable |
| Clipping in | Often double-sided | Usually single-sided |
| Suited to | Gravel, MTB, touring, commuting | Road bike, racing |
SPD-SL and the other road systems
Road pedals have a large platform and a large cleat. That gives a stable feel and spreads the load across your foot. Shimano SPD-SL and Look Keo are the most common; you will find cleats everywhere. Alongside them sit Time and Speedplay, chosen mainly for their extra freedom of movement. Every road system works with three-bolt shoes; Speedplay uses an adapter plate for that.
Our favourite is the Shimano Ultegra PD-R8000: dependable, a wide platform and available with a longer spindle. The Look Keo 2 Max is a cheaper way in.
SPD for gravel and mountain biking
SPD pedals use a small metal cleat recessed into a lugged sole. So you can simply walk, which is worth a lot on gravel, on the mountain bike and at coffee stops. They clip in easily, often from either side, and the system copes well with mud. The Shimano XT PD-M8100 is the standard; the Crankbrothers Eggbeater 3 clips in more easily still when it is muddy.
Which should you choose for gravel?
For gravel we almost always choose SPD. You walk sections more often, step off at a steep pitch or a gate, and the surface is loose. A road cleat wears quickly then, and you slip on wet stone. If you ride gravel mostly on surfaced terrain and rarely step off, a road system can work, but for most riders SPD is the better choice.
Float: important for your knees
Float is how freely your foot can rotate while clipped in. A little float stops your knee being forced into an unnatural angle. Shimano offers cleats with 0, 2 and 6 degrees, Look with 0, 4.5 and 9 degrees. The Time XPRO 12 has 10 degrees plus some lateral play, and on the Wahoo Speedplay Zero you set float from 0 to 15 degrees. If you have knee trouble, start with more float and have your cleats set up properly.
Do not forget your shoes
Your pedal decides your shoe. Road shoes have three bolt holes, gravel and MTB shoes two. So choose them together. See our top lists of pedals and cycling shoes.