How we choose
A buying guide is only worth something once you know how it came about. So here is what our choices are based on, what we do not do, and how we make money.
Who makes CycleRanks
CycleRanks was started by Alan, who has worked in the bike trade for years: in the workshop and behind the counter. Our recommendations come from that practice: what we fit, set up and ride ourselves. Read more about Alan and CycleRanks.
What our choices are based on
- Workshop experience
- What we fit, adjust and repair day in day out. Which products run trouble-free and which keep coming back.
- Long-term experience
- What people are still happy to ride months later, and what they go off.
- Our own miles
- What we ride ourselves. If we mention our own experience, it was genuinely earned.
- Specifications and compatibility
- Whether something fits your bike, your pedals or your rims. A product that does not fit is never the best choice.
What our stars mean
Every product carries a rating from Alan, in whole and half stars. It stands for how good that product is for the rider it is meant for, at its own price. A €105 saddle can therefore score as highly as a €449 one: we are not holding them up against each other, but against what you are entitled to expect for the money.
You will see very few low ratings here, and that is no accident: anything we would not recommend does not go on the list at all. The stars are about the differences between products that are all worth having.
- 5 stars
- We would buy it ourselves without looking any further.
- 4.5 stars
- Excellent, with one small reservation.
- 4 stars
- Good, and it does what it promises. There may be something better, but it costs more.
- 3.5 stars
- It does the job, with compromises you should know about beforehand.
What we do not do
- No invented tests
- We do not quote test miles, measurements or rider weights that were never actually recorded.
- No calculated scores
- Our stars are a judgement, not the output of a scoring model. You will not find figures like 8.4 out of ten here, which imply a precision that does not exist.
- No paid placements
- Brands cannot buy a position in our lists.
How we make money
Some links on CycleRanks are partner links. If you buy something at a shop through such a link, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. That is how the site is paid for. Which products we recommend is decided separately from that commission.
Quasar Wheels is our own brand. Whenever we recommend Quasar we always say so, so you know we have a direct interest in it.
Prices and currency
Prices on CycleRanks are indicative and shown in euros. You will see the current price in the shop you click through to. We update the lists when new models arrive or when our experience changes.
Spotted something wrong?
Seen a mistake, or do you disagree with something? Email us at info@cycleranks.com. We are happy to put it right.