Garmin Edge or Wahoo Elemnt: which bike computer should you choose?
It is the question we get most often in the shop. The answer depends less on the device than you might think, and more on how you plan and ride.
The short answer
If you want as many features as possible and you navigate a lot, choose Garmin; the Garmin Edge 850 is the best pick for most riders. If you want a device you set up through your phone and that then simply works, choose Wahoo; the Wahoo Elemnt Roam V3 gives the best value. If you ride SRAM AXS, or want a device that works like a smartphone, look at the Hammerhead Karoo 3.
Controls: touch, buttons or both
Garmin offers both worlds. The Edge 550 runs on buttons only, the Edge 850 on buttons and a touchscreen, and the Edge 1050 mainly on the touchscreen. Wahoo gives the Roam V3 buttons and a touchscreen, but you make most settings in the app. Hammerhead leans on the touchscreen, with a few buttons for the basics.
Buttons are more dependable with gloves and in the rain; a touchscreen is nicer for panning around a map. For most riders a combination is ideal.
Navigation and routes
Every device in our list has maps and can reroute if you go off course. The difference is in the detail. With the Edge 850 and 1050 you can build a route on the device itself, point by point, without a phone. Those two also have a speaker for voice navigation. With Wahoo you plan in the app or in Komoot by preference. With all three big brands, Komoot routes sync automatically.
Battery life in practice
| Model | Claimed | Practice / battery saver |
|---|---|---|
| Garmin Edge 850 | 12 h heavy use | up to 36 h in battery saver |
| Garmin Edge 1050 | 20 h | up to 60 h in battery saver |
| Wahoo Elemnt Roam V3 | 25 h | around 20 h in practice |
| Hammerhead Karoo 3 | 15 h | |
| Bryton Rider S810 | 50 h | 20 to 30 h in practice |
Claimed figures are often measured in a low-power mode. With navigation, a bright screen and plenty of sensors you will land lower. If you regularly ride for more than ten hours, work with the real-world figure.
Ecosystem: that is where the real difference sits
Garmin Connect is comprehensive: training plans, recovery status and links to Garmin watches and the Varia radar. That is powerful, but it is also a lot. Wahoo keeps things simpler and works closely with its own trainers and power meters. Since the SRAM takeover, Hammerhead is strongest at integrating with AXS groupsets: you see your gear and battery status directly, for instance.
If you already have a Garmin watch, a Garmin bike computer usually makes the most sense. If you have a Wahoo trainer, an Elemnt slots in neatly. Both brands work perfectly well with sensors from other makers, incidentally.
Our pick by type of rider
- All-round, lots of navigation
- Garmin Edge 850: touch and buttons, bright screen, route building on the device.
- Value for money
- Wahoo Elemnt Roam V3: colour maps, long battery life, simple to operate.
- Simple and compact
- Wahoo Elemnt Bolt V3: light, uncluttered, ideal for training.
- Big screen, long days
- Garmin Edge 1050: the largest screen and the longest battery in saver mode.
- Tight budget
- Bryton Rider S810: plenty of features for the money, with OpenStreetMap maps.